Our Menu

Gaetano’s of Penny Packer is open
Monday-Sunday: 11am-8pm

For the best viewing experience, rotate your phone 90 degrees.

APPETIZERS

(5) Fried Mozzarella Sticks w/ Marinara Sauce $7.85
Garlic Bread $5.45
Garlic Bread w/ Cheese $7.15
Chili $5.49
Chili w/ Cheese $7.15
(6) Cream Cheese Poppers $8.50
Buffalo Chicken Bites w/ Bleu Cheese $7.75
(3) Pazotti Bites (Cheese) $6.85
Clam Strips $5.95
Chicken Tenders w/ Fries $7.10
Chicken Nuggets $6.25
Battered Mushrooms w/ Horseradish Sauce $7.90
Butterfly Shrimp w/ Fries (Buffalo or Cajun) $9.45
Chicken Cheesesteak Egg Rolls $6.80
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls $6.80

FRIES

French Fries $4.49
French Fries with Gravy $5.90
French Fries with Bacon and Ranch $5.90
French Fries with Choice of Cheese $6.75
Spicy Curly or Waffle Fries $5.49
Spicy Curly or Waffle Fries with Cheese $7.25
Pizza Fries $7.25
Onion Rings $6.00
Buffalo Fries with Blue Cheese $6.15
Sweet Potato Fries $6.00

STEAK CUT FRIES

Fries $5.10
Fries with Gravy $5.90
Fries with Gravy and Cheese $6.75
Fries with Gravy, Cheese and Ground Beef $9.49

SALADS

All Salad Are Served with Bread and 4 oz. Dressing – Extra Dressing 0.50

Garden Salad
(Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Cabbage, Broccoli & Olives)
  Small
$9.00
  Large
$11.00
…….. add Crispy or Grilled Chicken for $7.00 extra
Antipasto Salad
(Lettuce w/ Capicola, Salami, Sharp Provolone, Pepperoni, Tomatoes, Olives, Red Onions & Cabbage)
$15.60
Turkey and Cheese
(Over Lettuce w/ Tomatoes, Red Onions and Red Cabbage)
$15.60
Ham and Cheese
(Over Lettuce w/ Tomatoes, Red Onions and Red Cabbage)
$15.60
Tuna Salad w/ Cheese
(Over Lettuce w/ Tomatoes, Red Onions and Red Cabbage)
$15.85
Chicken Salad w/ Cheese
(Over Lettuce w/ Tomatoes, Red Onions and Red Cabbage)
$15.85
Chef’s Salad
(Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef and Swiss over Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions & Red Cabbage)
$16.25
Caesar Salad
(Fresh Romaine Topped w/ Tomatoes, Croutons, Egg, Broccoli & Red Onions)
$13.95
………. add Crispy or Grilled Chicken for $3.00 extra
Taco Salad
(Sour Cream, Fried Tortilla Shells, White Cheddar, Ground Beef, Hot Peppers and Tomatoes)
$15.60
BLT Salad
(Romaine and Iceberg Lettuce Topped w/ Cheddar, Diced Tomoates, Bacon & Ranch Dressing)
$15.60
………. add Grilled or Crispy Chicken for $4.50 extra

Available Dressings: Italian – Ranch – French – Bleu Cheese – Caesar – Thousand Island
Additional Dressings – $0.55

HOT DOGS

Hot Dog $2.09
Chili Dog $2.99
Chili Dog w/ Cheese $3.59
Italian w/ Fried Onions, Green Peppers & Potatoes $3.99

STEAKS

  Roll
End
  8″
Mini
  12″
Sm.
  17″
Lg.
Steak $7.55   $13.40   $18.90   $25.90
Cheese Steak $7.80   $13.65   $19.20   $25.95
Pizza Steak $8.05   $14.30   $19.75   $26.70
Steak Hoagie (w/ Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions)   $14.00   $19.40   $26.50
Cheese Steak Hoagie (w/ Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions)   $14.30   $19.85   $26.80
Jersey Steak (Potatoes, Gr. Peppers, Fried Onions & A-1 Sauce)   $14.30   $19.90   $27.00
with Cheese   $14.10   $20.25   $27.45
The Don Cheese Steak (Grilled Tomatoes, Oregano, Parmesan, Sharp & Mild Provolone)   $14.10   $20.25   $27.55
Jake the “Sicilian Steak” (Italian Ham, Salami and Pepperoni —    $13.80   $19.90   $27.20
with Sharp Provolone   $14.20   $20.25   $27.55
Mr. Gee’s Cheese Steak (Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Sauteed Onions and Pepperoni w/ Cheese)   $14.00   $19.90   $27.55
Steak Italiano (Fried Onions, Tomato, Spinach and Sausage served on garlic bread with Sharp and Mile Provolone)   $14.65   $21.20   $28.45

CHICKEN STEAKS

  Roll
End
  8″
Mini
  12″
Sm.
  17″
Lg.
Chicken Steak $6.05   $12.90   $18.10   $24.45
Chicken Cheese Steak $6.30   $13.05   $18.35   $24.75
Pizza Cheese Steak $6.55   $13.35   $18.75   $25.45
Chicken Cheese Steak Hoagie   $13.40   $18.65   $25.25
Jersey Chicken Steak (Potatoes, Green Peppers, Fried Onions & BBQ Sauce)   $13.70   $18.85   $25.65
with Cheese   $13.90   $19.05   $25.85
Barbeque Chicken Cheese Steak   $13.30   $18.60   $25.35
Boston Chicken Cheese Steak (Chicken Steak, Ham, BBQ Sauce & Cheese)   $13.95   $18.85   $26.00
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak (Chicken Steak Topped w/ Buffalo Sauce and Bleu Cheese Dressing)   $13.75   $19.05   $25.65
Cajun Chicken Cheese Steak (Chicken Steak Topped w/ Spicy Cajun Sauce)   $13.75   $18.85   $25.65
Chicken Caesar Cheese Steak (Romaine, Tomatoes, Boiled Egg and Caesar Dressing)   $13.90   $19.05   $25.85
Chicken Italiano (Spinach, Sharp & Mild Provolone, Fried Onions, Tomatoes, served on Garlic Bread)   $13.90   $19.05   $25.85

EXTRAS

Pricing Available Upon Request…

  Mushrooms Pepperoni  
  Green Peppers Sausage  
  Sweet Peppers Bacon  
  Pickles Egg  
  Extra Cheese Potato  
  Provolone (Sharp/Mild) A-1 Steak Sauce  
  Fried Onions    

HOMEMADE BURGERS

  8″
Mini
  12″
Sm.
  17″
Lg.
Hamburger $8.95   $12.65   $16.65
Cheeseburger $9.55   $13.20   $17.50
Pizza Burger $10.00   $13.90   $17.75
Jersey Burger (w/ Green Peppers, Potatoes, Fried Onions & A-1 Sauce) $10.50   $14.25   $18.15
Pepper Jack Burger $10.10   $14.20   $18.40
TGR Burger (Pork Roll and Cheese, cooked in a Hot BBQ Sauce) $10.10   $14.20   $18.40
Lettuce, Tomatoes or Onions on any burger $0.90   $1.00   $1.00

HOAGIES

All Hoagies come with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Salt, Pepper, Oregano and Oil and Vinegar

  8″
Mini
  12″
Sm.
  17″
Lg.
American $10.25   $14.65   $20.85
Italian $10.45   $15.05   $21.15
American Cheese $10.40   $14.35   $21.05
3 Cheese Hoagie $10.55   $14.85   $21.00
Tuna Salad and Cheese $11.00   $15.45   $22.10
Roast Beef and Cheese $11.75   $16.55   $23.45
Roasted Turkey and Cheese $11.95   $15.85   $22.75
Ham and Cheese $11.10   $15.85   $22.35
Chicken Salad $11.25   $15.95   $23.05
Egg Salad $10.45   $15.65   $20.75
Vegetarian Hoagie (Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers & Olives) $9.55   $13.45   $19.45
Skip Hoagie (Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef and American Cheese) $10.75   $14.55   $20.45
Big Tony Hoagie (Capicola, Genoa, Mild Provolone, Peppered Ham & Prosciutto) $10.85   $14.75   $20.40

HOT SANDWICHES

  8″
Mini
  12″
Sm.
  17″
Lg.
Chicken Cutlet w/ Sauce $12.05   $15.85   $23.20
Chicken Cutlet Hoagie (Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions) $12.30   $16.15   $23.65
Chicken Parmigiana $12.45   $16.55   $23.55
Veal Parmigiana $13.00   $17.95   $24.60
Pork Roll $11.55   $17.30   $21.75
Pork Roll with Cheese $11.55   $17.75   $22.35
Flounder with Sauce $11.70   $15.60   $22.65
Flounder Hoagie $12.20   $16.45   $23.25
Flounder Parmigiana $12.25   $16.50   $23.35
Sausage Peppers and Onion $11.85   $15.75   $23.15
Meatball and Sauce $11.45   $15.55   $22.45
Meatball Parmigiana $11.85   $16.15   $23.25
Peppers and Eggs $11.15   $14.95   $22.10
Peppers and Eggs with Cheese $11.85   $15.60   $22.45
Hot Roast Beef with Gravy $12.55   $16.20   $24.50
Eggplant Parmigiana $12.15   $14.95   $22.10
Baked Ham and Cheese $10.85   $14.35   $20.55
Sausage Parmigiana $11.85   $15.75   $23.15
Clamwich $10.45   $14.65   $21.45
Kielbasa $10.55   $13.30   $18.70
Quinn’s Kielbasa (Fried Onions, Green Peppers & Hot BBQ Sauce) $10.55   $14.30   $22.45
BLT Hoagie (with Mayo on a Toasted Roll) $11.95   $16.75   $23.35

WRAPS

Cajun Chicken Wrap – Sliced Grilled Chicken Breast w/ Cajun Spices, American Cheese, Tomato and Ranch Dressing   $11.25
Chicken Salad Wrap with Lettuce and Tomato   $11.25
Chicken Caesar Wrap – Romaine Lettuce, Red Onion and Caesar Dressing   $11.25
Chicken Ranch Wrap – Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Red Onions, Crispy Bacon and Cool Ranch Dressing   $11.25
Vegetable Wrap – Broccoli, Mushroom, Black Olives, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions & Italian Dressing   $11.25
Cheese Steak Wrap – Cheese Steak with Peppers, Mushrooms and Fried Onions   $11.25
Chicken Cheese Steak Wrap – Chicken Cheese Steak with Lettuce, Tomato and Fried Onions   $11.25
Turkey Wrap – Turkey Breast, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo with Your Choice of Cheese   $11.25
Mozzarella Steak Wrap – Steak and Mozzarella Cheese with Side of Sauce   $11.25
Taco Wrap – Beef, Hot Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese and Sour Cream   $11.25
Chicken Tender Wrap with Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato   $11.25
BLT Wrap with Mayo   $11.25
Buffalo Chicken Wrap with Bleu Cheese   $11.25
Tuna Salad Wrap with Cheese, Lettuce and Tomato   $11.25

PIZZA BREAD

Mini – 8″ $3.95
Toppings $0.60
Small – 12″ $4.25
Toppings $0.90
Large – 18″ $5.95
Toppings $1.20

PIZZA · STROMBOLI · CALZONES

16″ Plain Pie Call
         Extra Call
         Steak Call
         Chicken Call
Calzone or Stromboli Call
         Extra Call
         Steak Call
         Chicken Call

PASTA

All Pastas Served with Bread, Butter and a Salad with Your Choice of Dressing

Available Dressings: Italian – Ranch – French – Bleu Cheeese – Caesar – Thousand Island

Spaghetti and Meatballs $15.85
Penne and Meatballs $15.85
Ravioli and Meatballs $16.25
Baked Penne with Meatballs $18.25
Chicken Parmigiana $20.45
Veal Parmigiana $23.45
Side of Sausage $3.95
Side of Meatballs $3.95
Child’s Spaghetti or Penne with 1 Meatball and Bread $6.95

WING DINGS OR WING ZINGS

Dry Breaded Mild Wing Dings or Dry Breaded Hot Wing Zings

Hot Sauce or Bleu Cheese

7 Wing dings or Wing Zings (with one sauce) $11.80 $8.40
13 Wing dings or Wing Zings (with one sauce) $22.25 $15.60
20 Wing dings or Wing Zings (with 2 sauces)  $28.00 $24.00
50 Wing dings or Wing Zings (with 2 8 oz. sauces) $84.50 $60.00